Posts Tagged ‘strategy’

Stop Calling Me A Social Media Marketing Expert

March 8th, 2010 - Jeff Turner

I’ve tried hard to not call myself a social media marketing expert or guru or master or rock star. What I haven’t done is correct others when they have. And I haven’t done a very good job of letting people know what I really am or what I’m really good at.

That’s all about to change.

I’ve spent at least a year in a complete blogging funk. And it’s not because I don’t have things I’d like to say. I most certainly do. The reason for the funk is that I’ve been having an internal battle between “what I should be doing” and “what I really love to do.” Luckily for me, what I really love to do is also what I’m really good at. And it’s not creating and defining marketing strategies.

First, some commentary. A troubling trend has emerged from the chaos of the social media boom. People who have no real marketing skills or training or any experience with business strategy are becoming “social media marketing” consultants, strategists and coaches based on a few factors that have nothing to do with successful marketing strategy. These new marketing “experts” fall into one of three categories.

  • The Cheerleader
  • The Successful Fool
  • The Opportunist

The Cheerleader

You all know this social media marketing expert. He or she is the person who has no proven track record for building ANYTHING other than followers on a few popular social media sites. They equate this popularity with business success and can even teach others how to recreate their “success” in these online venues. They use anecdote and analogy to answer questions of ROI and they universally fail to be able to point to any quantifiable measures of business progress that contribute substantially to a company’s bottom line.

The Successful Fool

This social media marketing expert has a proven track record of past business success, but it has nothing to do with any marketing experience, least of which social media marketing. There is no proof that their journey is repeatable. They use an unintentional slight of hand to direct our attention to their past exploits as proof positive of future benefit. And they make the foolish mistake of thinking their personal ability to grow a business can be transferred to others on a large scale.

The Opportunist

This is my least favorite form of new age social media marketing expert. They promise big results with almost no effort. They are the social media marketing snake oil salesmen. They’re the ones telling you that if you don’t do x and y you will be extinct in 2 years. Their success is measured in the number of people they dupe into buying their placebos. They’re not marketing strategists, they’re carnival barkers.

So what am I?

I have been very successful in my business life. Let me be clear, by “very successful” I mean that my companies have made solid profits for many years. But they have not been successful because I am a marketing strategy expert. Quite to the contrary.

What has helped make them successful is hiring great strategy consultants and partnering with great strategic thinkers, like Bill Leider. I’ve have also tried to align myself with others who are great marketing and brand strategists in specific market segments, like Marc Davison in real estate. But I am NOT a marketing strategist. What I do is work WITH and BESIDE marketing strategists to develop tools, tactics and technology paths that make executing those strategies simpler and easier. I look at a company’s objectives and devise ways to use technology to make executing those strategies more efficient and effective. I am a tactical strategist and a technology strategist. I am not a marketing strategist – social media or otherwise.

The mistake I’ve made over the past year is thinking that I needed to be something else. I don’t.

When Hal Lublin related the story of how, while playing poker, Chris Brogan helped him understand that he shouldn’t hold back, I wondered why I was holding back. I wondered what was keeping me from writing. And I’ve come to the conclusion that there is no one good reason. There is just one bad reason – I’ve been resisting being seen as a social media MARKETING expert.

My Master’s degree is in School Psychology with a focus on behavior modification. I spent several years creating behavior modification plans for severely mentally handicapped and criminally insane patients. So, if sometimes I want to write about behavior, I should. I have a passion for science, so sometimes I want to write about technology, the Internet and social media as it relates to quantum mechanics and complex adaptive systems. There’s no reason why I shouldn’t. I’ve also spent a great deal of time dissecting, with the help of some great thinkers, the role of vision and values in building and managing a business and solidifying a brand. I should write about that too. I will.

But what I will not do is continue to allow my resistance to being lumped into the category of “social media marketing expert” keep me from writing about areas in which I excel. I’m going to write about emerging digital tools and how to make them work to the benefit of strategy – personal, brand, marketing or otherwise. I’m going to write about what I love – technology.

Taking the experts’ advice.

The social media marketing experts I admire tell me that if I want to increase engagement, I should ask a question at the end of each blog post. Let’s see if they’re right. What barriers are holding you back from being more effective in using social media?

The Lure Of The Shiny Object

November 25th, 2009 - Jeff Turner

The Lure Of The Shiny ObjectSome very well meaning, very smart people are being distracted by the lure of shiny objects. And they are distracting others in the process.

The sexiness of the social media space and the desire to see an immediate return on the time investment required to access it, has created an atmosphere ripe for solutions to problems that don’t really exist.  Example: Tweetlister.

Tweetlister launched in May of 2009. It allows the “tweeting” of real estate listings into a user’s Twitter stream. It gives real estate agents the ability to “post and re-use as many listings as you want.”

Funny, I thought Twitter already gave them that ability.

My first response, six months ago, came in the form of a tweet. I said, “Here’s an example of a solution in search of a problem if I’ve ever seen one.” And this was all I intended to write about it. Besides, Nicole Nicolay had already done a good job of exposing the shiny object.

But it didn’t go away. This private twitter conversation, a few weeks later,  should have given me a clue that this would be a very distracting shiny object. It was sent to me by an extremely bright executive from one of the largest real estate companies in America.

Them: “Good concept – I definitely see this tool being abused.”

Me: Why is it a good concept? Why would you want to push people to yet another 3rd party listing site? Why not your own?”

Them: “That was a duh moment when I read your response. I’m a twitter newbie. Still learning & having fun. Thanks for the schooling.”

That wasn’t schooling. I didn’t teach them anything they didn’t know already. I just wasn’t distracted by the shiny object and simply asked a few questions to make sure there was something worth biting on the hook. But several very smart people, people I resprect and also call friends, did bite. And then they told their friends to bite. They’re still biting.

I posed the following question on the post linked above; “Your listings are probably already on your site or your blog. If you really want to automate, you could use Tweetlater (or Hootsuite or Objective Marketer or CoTweet) and set up a similar kind of schedule. Then the links would come straight to you. This just gets in the way, IMHO.” Agents could be leading buyers to their site and to their IDX search, but instead they are tweeting away and leading them to a search site they have no control over, one that is not a destination search site and one that could easily lead the buyer to another agent. And they are paying $9.95 a month for that right. I still don’t get it.

I’ve been thinking about this for six months. Why do smart people spend so much time leading people away from the sites they own? Why aren’t people employing a more focused hub and spoke approach to how they use social media? Why aren’t brokers providing more intelligent tools to help their agents?

That thinking has lead me in several directions, one of them being how the real estate virtual tour business works and how we do things at Real Estate Shows. The result of my thinking? Real Estate Shows needs to get out of the middle of the real estate transaction to the greatest extent possible. When consumers search on sites like Trulia and Zillow and Realtor.com, if they click on a link to a virtual tour, it should lead to a site owned by the real estate agent, not to yet another third party site.

How do we do that? I have a few ideas, but this post is already too long. The answer lies in being more intelligent with how our links work and becoming invisible to the consumer. More to come.

Nothing Is Free

August 23rd, 2009 - Bill Leider

Social Media is growing like the plague and it’s here for the long term.
It is permeating almost everything we do and see and buy and use. We know this:

  • People want to participate in everything.
  • They want to frame the discussion.
  • They don’t want to be talked to. They want to be part of the discussion.
  • They want to have input on the structure and construction of the products and services they buy.
  • Recommendations from other users are more valuable than clever buying messages.

The notion that monetization, measurements of effectiveness and ROI are to be abandoned in the Social Media world is a foolish argument. It’s the same kind of nonsense that permeated the dot.com world and led to its meltdown. In the years leading to the dot com crash, the “experts” were saying that monetization was an obsolete concept. It was ancient economics made irrelevant by modern technology. In hindsight, intelligent venture capitalists lost their sanity and threw millions of dollars at ideas that would never earn a nickel. That message was crap back then. It still is.

Ask yourself these questions:

  • How would you use Twitter if every Tweet and Retweet you sent cost $1, or $5?
  • How would you use Facebook if it cost $200 to set up your Facebook page and every posting cost you $2?
  • How would you write blog posts if it cost everyone who read your posts $1 per post?
  • What is it about “free” content that makes so many people waste so much time?
  • Why does a “free” platform seduce people into believing that it’s wrong to have a financial purpose for what they do?

We’ll be talking more about this. And providing some answers. Stay tuned.

Using Social Media To Strengthen Your Brand

August 17th, 2009 - Bill Leider

Ever since the word brand (a noun) was expanded to branding (a verb) interpretive misunderstandings about what “brand” and “branding” really are have multiplied. Various self-proclaimed gurus (consultants above criticism) have written about the sins of misguided “branding.” Unfortunately, too often, they themselves didn’t know what a brand or branding were either. So they just added to the confusion and the body of misconceptions masquerading as wisdom.

Simply stated, your “Brand” (the noun) can be defined as what you deliver and how you deliver it. The quality of your Brand is determined by how closely aligned  the experiences of your customers are between what they expect vs. what they get.

Every single thing you, as an organization, do or don’t do factors into the equation of brand definition and brand strength. That goes way beyond advertising, marketing and sales.

Branding (the verb) is about two things:

  • Spreading the word about who and what you are; getting and keeping your name out there. It creates name recognition, top of mind and back of mind awareness; and
  • Making promises and creating expectations in the minds of your current and potential customers. It is supposed to increase sales (duh).

Advertising and ad campaigns do not strengthen brands.

They build awareness, they communicate promises and create expectations. They can be clever, cute, creative, entertaining, informational, confrontational, sexy and more. But they do not strengthen Brands. Brands are strengthened when the promises are kept, when peoples’ expectations are met or exceeded. Brand strengthening is experiential. Advertising is informational.

Enter Social Media. It presents a powerful opportunity. If you develop and execute a sound Social Media strategy you can cost effectively strengthen and support your Brand and improve the effectiveness of your Branding.

Here are some things to consider.

  • Develop a comprehensive Social Media strategy. If you don’t have a well-thought out strategy, what you have is a hobby. The odds of achieving financial success with a hobby are similar to those for winning the lottery.
  • •    Your strategy should be broad and deep. In other words it must encompass more than building name recognition and trying to increase sales. Think about how you can use Social Media to engage your customers and prospects in meaningful discussions about what they want from you: your products; your product support; new products/services and new features. Enable your customers to tell you about their experiences with your “Brand:” what they like and what they don’t like. Listen. Respond. Do it publicly. Transparency is the path to trust. Use the information you get to improve, to fix what is broken and to build on what works well.
  • •    Determine whom you want to engage? What do you want to discuss and learn? What outcomes/results do you want to achieve?
  • Coordinate and integrate Social Media with all other forms of marketing going on in your organization. Take into account the behavioral/cultural changes that you must effect in this process.
  • Transition your culture to embrace transparency. This is much easier said than done. But consider that much of the information that for centuries was deemed confidential is now considered public. People want to be part of an ongoing dialog. They want to know what is happening. They want to participate in and help shape discussions, and more. If they don’t like where the conversation is going, they want the power to shift it. Let them – or they will leave. Social Media is not about pushing your message down the throats of your audience. It is about conversations. It is about you learning by listening.
  • Choose your Social Media platforms and your communication programs and processes with all of the above in mind. Technology just provides the tools. Knowing which tools to use should come as a result of first determining all of the elements above. Don’t be seduced by the buzz of tech toys. Letting the hype about any particular piece of technology make your decisions for you is orchestrating frustration at best and disaster at worst.

Social Media should not replace or compete with anything you currently do that works effectively and profitably. Done well, it should enrich everything.

Looking At Problems Differently

June 6th, 2009 - Jeff Turner

I have known and worked with Bill Leider for almost two decades.

Bill Leider Doing New York Times Sunday Crossword

We share a common set of values, yet we are nothing alike. When we returned from our recent trip to Philadelphia, where both Bill and I served as advisors to The Social Media Marketing Institute, the photo on the right jumped out at me.

As is his practice, he prints out the Sunday New York Times crossword puzzles and brings them with him on trips. The New York Times crossword puzzles are considered some of the trickiest puzzles around. Bill can rip through these crossword puzzles faster than anyone I’ve ever met.

I realized something important as I looked at this photo. The crossword puzzles are the perfect illustration of what makes Bill so good at breaking down business problems and helping companies solve them in ways that produce exceptional results.

Solving a crossword puzzle requires a good understanding of crossword conventions, puzzle logic and a broad general knowledge (vocabulary, literature, culture, art, sciences, geography, etc.). You can learn the conventions and logic relatively quickly, but the general knowledge is what separates the men from the boys. All the tricks and techniques in the world won’t help you solve the puzzles if you’re lacking the general knowledge and the ability to tie them all together.

Bill’s unwillingness to accept the first answer, the answer everyone can see, can be frustrating to some. But first answers often relate to symptoms, not the true, underlying issue or opportunity. I know in our early dealings, I found myself wanting to strangle him. Truth be told, I still do. But what always comes from his ability to see the hidden clues, from his creative approach to asking questions, from his desire to “solve the puzzle,” is a unique perspective on every situation. Even his “wrong” answers and seemingly unrelated questions open your eyes to new possibilities. They help you figure out the clues to solving your own puzzles.

If you’re willing.

Waltzing To A Samba – The Real World Realities Of Changing Your Organization

May 12th, 2009 - Bill Leider

Today you have before you a dizzying, dazzling, daunting array of new platforms, tools and techniques for changing the way you do business.

Conferences all over the country, blogs from every corner of the world are filled with the voices of revolutionary thinkers telling you how to blow up your company, start over with a clean sheet of paper and build the dream organization of tomorrow.

I don’t hear the visionaries talking about what you should do with the organization you already have; the one you spent years building; the one in which you have a significant investment; the one that you rely on for your financial and emotional sustenance.

We also have a body of experts telling you how to defend and sustain the status quo: how your message about your value proposition can be repositioned so that doing what you’ve always done for the prices you’ve traditionally charged will suddenly seem appealing to the public. A slick new web site, a new ad campaign and life is good. Comfort food for the delusional.

I don’t hear any meaningful talk about transition; that fear filled journey from current reality into the unknown and out the other side to a more successful future.

Let’s consider just three basic elements of your present reality:

Your current fixed costs:
You have leases or mortgage payments on your premises. You cannot wish them away because you went to a workshop and imagined the brokerage of the future. So assuming you want to redesign your traditional brick and mortar presence into something better attuned to emerging consumer wants and needs, then time – transition time – must become a part of your thinking and planning.

While you are waiting (and perhaps negotiating yourself out of some current leases) the question arises, what do you do during this fixed cost transition period? How do you blend your message and image and structure of the future with the physical and financial realities of the present? Surely, not everything you’re doing is bad, obsolete or unprofitable, as some of the pundits would have you believe. The world as you know it is not going to crash and burn in the next few months.

Your current culture:
You have people: Realtors/agents; administrative staff; marketing people; technology people. In all probability your Realtors are diverse in their views and their business methods. Some embrace the Internet, some cringe at having to turn on their computers. Some of the cringers may be your highest producers. Some of those skilled in the new technologies may lack the interpersonal skills to achieve great financial results. They all pay desk fees. They all carry business cards with your name on them. They all define who you are.

Over time you have created, both consciously and unconsciously, an organizational culture/dynamic, an established way of doing and being and interacting and getting things done and communicating and helping one another. You cannot take that cultural dynamic for granted and assume that it will sort itself out through a period of profound change.

Your current market(s) and customers:
The demographics and behaviors of your markets and customers will weigh significantly on how and at what pace you transform your business model. Not everyone wants to radically change. Not everyone will decide to do or not do business with you based on whether or not your company embodies the form and practices of the company of the future. Certainly some will. But how many? How quickly? What is the speed of the trend toward change? When do you reach the “tipping point?”

At the end of the day, the real value you deliver lies in helping people buy homes that meet their lifestyle and financial needs and sell homes at optimum prices in acceptable time frames. Everything else should support that value proposition.

You must protect and enhance your Brand. You must grow. You must optimize your bottom line. Your agents must do the same, for themselves and for the organization.

What does all this mean?
Change for change’s sake has never made good business sense. Self proclaimed “visionaries” who tell you to destroy what you have built because fashion dictates it have probably never run a successful company over a long period of time.

Still, you cannot ignore the winds of change. You cannot deny that technology is altering lives and life styles and the ways in which people engage, connect, form relationships and transact business. You cannot ignore shifting demographics and the resultant changes in the behaviors of the people who are spending their money to buy what you offer.

All of it demands that you, as a leader, use a well-reasoned sense of balance. You achieve that balance by choosing and investing in the right elements of the “new wave” of thought, of technology, of behavior – elements that will not destroy you in the process of transforming you.

One of those leading edge elements that can help you reshape your business is Social Media. Social Media offers an array of new engagement tools, creative behavioral approaches and cultural change mechanisms that can have a profound, positive impact on creativity and results without trampling on what is tried, true and effective. Social Media requires only a small financial investment and, executed correctly, a modest investment of time.

Most importantly, Social Media is not a fad.

Social Media is here to stay. And Social Media can become a hands-on, experiential metaphor for a variety of new behaviors that will define the organization of tomorrow, both inside and outside the Social Media world. In upcoming articles, we will discuss why all that is so and how to use Social Media effectively.

Stay tuned.